CPS Decision Not to Prosecute Mohamed Al Fayed Explored

The story of the Crown Prosecution Service’s (CPS) decision not to prosecute Mohamed Al Fayed at two different times brings to light critical discussions about the challenges within the justice system. Despite evidence presented by the police in both 2009 and 2015, the CPS determined that there was not a “realistic prospect of conviction” against the former Harrods owner. These decisions have sparked conversations about the intricacies and limitations of the judicial process.

Mohamed Al Fayed, who passed away last year, was accused by five women of rape, with additional claims of sexual misconduct from others. The former owner of Harrods and Fulham Football Club was never charged, despite the serious nature of the allegations. During the periods when these decisions were made, Sir Keir Starmer was the head of the CPS from 2008 to 2013. However, a spokesperson from Downing Street clarified that the Al Fayed case did not come across his desk. Similarly, Sir Max Hill KC, who led the CPS from 2018 to 2023, confirmed the case never reached his attention.

The CPS spokesperson emphasized that to bring forward a prosecution, there must be a substantial likelihood of conviction. After careful examination of the evidence presented in 2009 and 2015, the prosecutors did not find it sufficient to proceed. Furthermore, in 2018, 2021, and 2023, the CPS extended early investigative advice to the Metropolitan Police regarding the allegations. However, a full file of evidence necessary for formal involvement was absent in these instances, leading to no further action by the police.

This situation has been widely discussed, with Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson noting on Sky News’ Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips that violence against women had been a personal priority for Sir Keir Starmer during his tenure at the CPS. She highlighted potential issues with the evidence provided by the police, stressing the need for robust evidence to secure convictions. Meanwhile, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner voiced concerns over a culture where “powerful people who seem to get away with it” often avoid legal repercussions. Her statements on BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg reflected a widespread sentiment about ensuring justice applies to all, regardless of power or status.

The Metropolitan Police, through Commander Kevin Southworth, confirmed they investigated “various allegations of sexual offences” against Mr. Al Fayed, yet no charges were filed due to the lack of sufficient evidence. The force remains open to further inquiries should new information be presented.

Recent developments include over 150 inquiries made to a legal team representing alleged victims after a BBC documentary aired about Mohamed Al Fayed. These inquiries comprise a mix of survivors and individuals possessing evidence relevant to the case, highlighting the continued public interest and concern surrounding the accusations against the late billionaire.

As the legal landscape evolves, this case underscores the complexities faced by prosecutorial bodies in sexual offence allegations, especially involving high-profile individuals. The commitment to further investigations if new evidence arises demonstrates an ongoing dedication to pursue justice diligently and thoroughly.